Comotomo vs Tommee Tippee Bottles: Which One Feels Most Like Breastfeeding?

Posted by

Editorial

For many parents, one of the biggest hurdles after welcoming a baby is figuring out how to make the transition from breast to bottle as smooth as possible. Babies who are used to breastfeeding can sometimes reject bottles, or struggle with nipple confusion if the bottle design feels too different from the real thing. That’s where specialized baby bottles come in — designed to mimic the look, feel, and flow of breastfeeding.

Two of the most talked-about brands in this space are Comotomo and Tommee Tippee. Both promise to make feeding easier for babies who go back and forth between breast and bottle, but they take slightly different approaches in design, material, and overall experience. Parents often find themselves asking: Which one really feels most like breastfeeding?

In this guide, we’ll break down the differences between the two brands, compare them side by side, and highlight what real parents are saying. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of which bottle is the better fit for your baby — and for your own needs as a parent.

Quick Comparison: Comotomo vs Tommee Tippee

When you’re short on time, sometimes all you want is a clear side-by-side look. Here’s how Comotomo and Tommee Tippee bottles stack up across the features that matter most to parents:

Feature	Comotomo Bottles	Tommee Tippee Bottles
Nipple Design	Wide, soft silicone nipple designed to mimic natural breast shape and feel.	Closer to Nature nipple with a slightly narrower shape, also aimed at a natural latch.
Material	Entire bottle made of medical-grade silicone (soft and squeezable).	BPA-free plastic bottle with silicone nipple.
Anti-Colic System	Dual anti-colic vents built into the nipple.	Advanced venting valve helps reduce gas and fussiness.
Ease of Cleaning	Two-piece design with extra-wide neck; dishwasher safe.	Standard wide neck, but more parts than Comotomo; also dishwasher safe.
Sizes Available	5 oz and 8 oz bottles.	Wide variety: 5 oz, 9 oz, 11 oz, plus specialty bottles.
Best For	Parents whose babies refuse bottles or are very sensitive to nipple feel.	Parents looking for a good value and a variety of sizes/styles.

Brand Overviews

Comotomo Bottles Overview

Comotomo has gained a loyal following among parents for one main reason: the bottles really do feel different. Made entirely of medical-grade silicone, they’re soft, squeezable, and designed to closely resemble the breast. The wide, dome-shaped nipple encourages a natural latch, which can be a lifesaver if your baby is picky about bottle-feeding.

Why parents love them:

Ultra-soft, flexible nipple that mimics breastfeeding.
Wide-neck design makes cleaning incredibly easy.
Fewer parts compared to many anti-colic bottles.

Potential drawbacks:

More expensive than most alternatives.
Limited size options (mainly 5 oz and 8 oz).
Some parents find the soft body tricky to hold one-handed.

See Comotomo bottles on Amazon

Tommee Tippee Bottles Overview

Tommee Tippee is one of the most recognized baby brands worldwide, and their Closer to Nature bottles are specifically marketed as breastfeeding-friendly. The nipples are shaped to help babies latch naturally, and the bottles come in a variety of sizes and styles, from standard feeding bottles to advanced anti-colic versions.

Why parents love them:

Affordable and widely available.
Large product line with plenty of sizes and accessories.
Nipple design supports natural feeding and is accepted by most babies.

Potential drawbacks:

More parts to clean compared to Comotomo.
Some parents report faster nipple collapse during feeding.
Not as “breast-like” in feel as silicone bottles.

Check Tommee Tippee bottles on Amazon

Head-to-Head Comparison: Comotomo vs Tommee Tippee

Nipple Shape & Feel

The nipple is the most important part when it comes to choosing a bottle for breastfed babies. Comotomo’s nipple is wide, soft, and flexible, with a dome-like shape that’s meant to mimic the breast as closely as possible. Many parents say it’s one of the easiest bottles for babies who refuse to latch onto traditional nipples.

Tommee Tippee’s Closer to Nature nipple also has a natural shape, but it’s slightly narrower and firmer than Comotomo’s. It works well for most babies, though some breastfed infants notice the difference and may take longer to adjust.

Verdict: Comotomo tends to win for babies who are extremely sensitive to nipple shape and texture.

Anti-Colic Performance

Both brands integrate venting systems to help reduce gas and fussiness. Comotomo uses dual anti-colic vents in the nipple itself, which keeps air from mixing with milk. Parents often find it simple and reliable.

Tommee Tippee bottles use an advanced venting valve at the base of the nipple. While effective for many families, some parents report inconsistent performance, especially as nipples wear out over time.

Verdict: Comotomo offers a simpler, more consistent anti-colic design, while Tommee Tippee gives you more anti-colic product options at different price points.

Ease of Cleaning & Assembly

Comotomo bottles are famous for their wide neck and two-piece design. There are no tiny valves or complicated parts — just a bottle body and nipple. You can clean them quickly without special brushes, and they’re dishwasher safe.

Tommee Tippee bottles have more components, especially in the anti-colic versions. They’re still easy to clean with a bottle brush, but you’ll spend more time taking them apart and reassembling.

Verdict: If cleaning time is a dealbreaker, Comotomo is the clear winner.

Durability & Safety

Comotomo bottles are made entirely of medical-grade silicone. They’re soft and flexible, which babies love, but that also means they can wear out faster with heavy use. Silicone can also pick up discoloration over time.

Tommee Tippee bottles are BPA-free plastic. They’re rigid, lightweight, and hold up well with daily use. Since only the nipple is silicone, you won’t see as much discoloration or stretching.

Verdict: Tommee Tippee wins on long-term durability, while Comotomo offers a softer, more natural feel.

Price & Value for Money

Comotomo bottles sit at the premium end of the market. A starter set will usually cost more than Tommee Tippee, and replacement nipples are also pricier.

Tommee Tippee is budget-friendly, with starter kits and multi-packs often available at a lower price point. For families who need multiple bottles or want an affordable backup set, Tommee Tippee is easier on the wallet.

Verdict: Tommee Tippee is more affordable overall, but Comotomo’s design may be worth the extra investment if your baby struggles with bottle acceptance.

Which One Feels Most Like Breastfeeding? (Final Verdict)

When it comes to replicating the feel of breastfeeding, Comotomo bottles usually come out on top. The wide, ultra-soft silicone nipple and squeezable bottle body create a feeding experience that feels more natural to babies who are used to nursing. Many parents report that Comotomo was the only bottle their breastfed baby would accept without a struggle.

That said, Tommee Tippee bottles are still an excellent choice, especially for parents who want a more affordable option with plenty of sizes and styles to choose from. Their Closer to Nature nipple is well-designed and works well for most babies, even if it doesn’t feel quite as lifelike as Comotomo.

Who Should Choose Which?

Choose Comotomo if: Your baby is breastfed, tends to reject bottles, or you want the softest, most natural-feeling design available.
Choose Tommee Tippee if: You want a reliable, budget-friendly bottle that works for most babies and comes in a variety of sizes and accessories.

Ready to decide? Check today’s prices and see which works best for your baby:

Alternative Bottles Worth Considering

While Comotomo and Tommee Tippee are two of the most popular choices for parents looking for bottles that feel close to breastfeeding, they aren’t the only options worth exploring. If you’re still undecided or want to compare further, here are a few alternatives that consistently rank high with parents:

Dr. Brown’s Natural Flow

Known for their advanced anti-colic system, Dr. Brown’s bottles are often recommended for babies with gas, reflux, or frequent spit-up. The venting system is a bit more complex to clean, but many parents swear by them for reducing fussiness.

Check Dr. Brown’s bottles on Amazon

Philips Avent Natural

Philips Avent bottles feature a wide, breast-shaped nipple designed to encourage an easy latch. They’re simple to clean, widely available, and a strong middle-ground option between Comotomo’s soft silicone feel and Tommee Tippee’s affordability.

See Philips Avent Natural bottles on Amazon

Nanobebe

Nanobebe bottles have a unique breast-like shape that helps babies transition between breast and bottle more smoothly. They’re also designed to preserve nutrients during warming, which appeals to parents who pump and store breast milk.

Explore Nanobebe bottles on Amazon

Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Bottle for Breastfed Babies

Finding the right bottle can feel overwhelming, especially with so many options on the market. The good news is that once you know what to look for, the decision becomes much easier. Here are the key factors to keep in mind:

1. Nipple Shape and Flexibility

If your baby is breastfed, the nipple design is the most important factor. Look for wide, soft nipples that mimic the breast and encourage a natural latch. This reduces nipple confusion and makes the transition smoother.

2. Flow Rate

Babies who breastfeed are used to working for their milk, so a slow-flow nipple is best at the beginning. It prevents frustration, helps mimic breastfeeding, and avoids overfeeding.

3. Anti-Colic Features

Gas and reflux are common feeding struggles. Bottles with built-in venting systems — like those from Comotomo, Tommee Tippee, or Dr. Brown’s — help reduce air intake and make feeding more comfortable.

4. Material Preference

Silicone bottles (like Comotomo) are soft and breast-like but may wear out faster.
Plastic bottles (like Tommee Tippee) are lightweight and durable.
Glass bottles are sturdy and chemical-free but heavier to handle.

5. Ease of Cleaning

If you want to spend less time scrubbing, go for bottles with fewer parts and wide necks. A dishwasher-safe design is also a big time saver.

6. Budget Considerations

Price varies widely between brands. Comotomo tends to be a premium choice, while Tommee Tippee offers great value. Think about how many bottles you’ll need, plus the cost of replacement nipples over time.

Tip: Many parents find it helpful to start with a small set before committing. Babies can be surprisingly picky, and what works for one may not work for another.

FAQs: Comotomo vs Tommee Tippee Bottles

Are Comotomo bottles better than Tommee Tippee for newborns?

Both can work for newborns, but Comotomo bottles are often preferred if your baby is breastfed and sensitive to nipple shape. Their soft, wide silicone nipple makes it easier for babies to latch naturally. Tommee Tippee, however, is a great choice if you want an affordable set to start with.

Which is easier to clean: Comotomo or Tommee Tippee?

Comotomo is much easier to clean. The wide opening and two-piece design mean you can wash it without needing special brushes. Tommee Tippee bottles are still manageable, but the anti-colic versions have more parts to take apart and reassemble.

Do Comotomo bottles reduce colic?

Yes. Comotomo bottles feature dual anti-colic vents built directly into the nipple, which helps minimize swallowed air and reduces gas. Many parents report fewer tummy troubles compared to standard bottles.

Can Tommee Tippee bottles be used for breastfed babies?

Absolutely. Tommee Tippee’s Closer to Nature line was designed with breastfed babies in mind. While the nipple isn’t quite as soft as Comotomo’s, many babies accept it without issue.

Which lasts longer: Comotomo silicone bottles or Tommee Tippee plastic bottles?

Tommee Tippee plastic bottles usually last longer in terms of durability and resistance to wear. Comotomo bottles, made of silicone, may stretch or discolor over time, especially with frequent use and sterilization.

Final Thoughts & Recommendation

Choosing between Comotomo and Tommee Tippee really comes down to your baby’s needs and your own priorities as a parent.

If your baby is breastfed and especially sensitive to nipple shape or texture, Comotomo is the stronger choice. The soft silicone body and ultra-flexible nipple provide one of the most natural-feeling feeding experiences available, making it easier for babies to accept.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option that’s widely available and comes in a variety of sizes and styles, Tommee Tippee delivers great value. Their Closer to Nature line is trusted by millions of parents and works well for most babies without costing as much as Comotomo.

Both brands are excellent and safe options. Many parents even keep a few bottles from each brand on hand to see which one their baby prefers.

Ready to try them out? Check the latest deals and availability: